It’s a dilemma many vegetarians and vegans face: If I’ve given up meat for ethical reasons, should my pet be allowed to eat it?
It’s a fair question.
After all, it’s a little hard to justify the suffering and killing of some animals in order to ensure the welfare of others. In other words, why is it okay for your dog or cat to eat a chicken or goat or cow?
In the case of cats, the answer is easy: cats are obligate carnivores. This means that without MEAT in their diet, they will die. It’s that simple. There isn’t a single study that proves otherwise.
In the case of dogs, it’s a little trickier. But even holistic veterinarian, Dr Richard Pitcairn (who turned vegetarian himself for health and ethical reasons) says that in order to be healthy, all dogs need meat in their diet. Sure, you can monkey with proportion and add a good quantity of steamed veg (like carrots, broccoli and kale), but if you want your puppy to look and feel good, there’s got to be some meat protein in there. And ideally from a variety of sources (beef, chicken, bison, horse, lamb, etc).
We each have a line that we draw: this animal is okay to eat and that one isn’t. For example, some of us would never consider eating veal or horsemeat. Just as some of us could never munch on a dog steak (while it’s common to do so in certain cultures).
But here’s the thing: It’s okay for us to decide what we, human beings with free will, should eat. Is it okay for us to impose these choices on beings whose physiology dictates otherwise? After all, most of us have given up eating meat in order to help animals. We don’t want to support factory farms and animal cruelty. Makes sense. But in denying a carnivore (or omnivore, in the case of dogs) his share of animal protein, we’re certainly not making the world a better place for our animals.
So what’s a vegan to do?
Well, if you find you really hate the idea of feeding meat, consider a herbivorous pet. Like a bunny. Or a fish.
But if you feed meat, here’s how to do it ethically:
* Try and source it from ethical farmers.
* When you can, opt for free range and organic.
* Offal: Remember that our pets can be a wonderful way to ensure that the animals that are killed for food are honoured by being consumed fully. To your dog, chicken feet and beef heart and sheep’s brain are all yummy treats. And nutritious to boot!
And remember, nature created these beautiful creatures. And designed them to eat other beautiful creatures. It’s difficult for those of us who work hard to live by clear rules. Nature isn’t black and white. She’s murky. And tasty…


